Please note our Peter Pan and the Neverland Crew Halloween theme was from 2012, please excuse the terrible pictures and lighting. The ideas are still fun and helpful if you are looking for Peter Pan Halloween Costume ideas.
Only the Peter Pan costume was a store bought costume. I did find it super cheap at a thrift store though. The rest of our costumes were pure DIY or semi-homemade genius!
Peter Pan Costume Ideas
Captain Hook Costume
We took a little leeway with the Captain Hook costume in order to accommodate for the Arizona heat! We used a long sleeved dark red shirt in lieu of a heavy coat and tucked an ascot in at the neck. And yes he is wearing shorts.
It was a great warm weather compromise for him.
His hat was a red pirate hat that we attached a large white feather (found at Michaels) too. We rounded the Hook look out with a black wig and mustache, sword and hook.
Neverland Mermaid Costume
I borrowed my costume (Thanks Jenn!!). It was made using the Simplicity 4043 pattern. I added a thin long sleeve shirt and leggings in turquoise, thankfully turquoise is a popular color right now. Then attached starfish (found also at Michaels) to barrettes with a hot glue gun. It was a cute addition since my hair is pretty short for a mermaid!
Peter Pan Costume
This was a Disney Store Peter Pan costume and the only store bought costume in the group. I found it at a local consignment store last year and used store credit to purchase it. The hat is super cute and the costume was a total score! 
Mr. Smee Costume
This is my favorite costume of the bunch probably cause it came together so well. Check out my Mr. Smee costume post for complete details including how I made the Mr. Smee hat.
Captain Hook’s Pirate Crew Costumes
Hook’s crew wore bandanas, scarfs, vests and swords for their pirate look. Other pirate costume ideas include pirate hats, eye patches, wigs, large gold hoop earrings, and long sleeved white ruffled shirts.
Indian Chief and Tiger Lily Costumes
My sister in law Vanessa was the genius behind these total DIY costumes. She did fantastic. So fantastic that I am going post the details separate with more pictures. Indian Chief and Tiger Lily DIY Details are HERE!
Tinker Bell
Tinker Bell is one of the Peter Pan costumes that you can easily buy. However most adult version are “sexy” which might not be the look you are going for. My other sister in law pulled together a cute tink look with a green shirt, green tutu and green tights! Add fairy wings and you are set! She is wearing official Disneyland fairy wings that light up and are extra fun!
Tick Tock Croc
I think Tick Tock Croc was the most difficult costume to make. This is another sweet costume that deserves a little extra DIY detail. Check out the details HERE!
Tootles Lost Boy Costume
All the Lost Boys in Disney’s Neverland are dressed in animal costumes. Tootles wears a skunk costume. Our Tootles wore black shorts, a black shirt and a skunk hat. I don’t think we could have convinced him wear a skunk tail but it would make a nice addition to the costume.
Wendy Darling Costume
Wendy’s costume was a fairly easy look to pull together. A plain, old fashioned blue nightgown was purchased (ebay). Dark blue ribbon (also bought at Michaels) was used around the waist and in her hair. My mom opted for a blonde wig since she couldn’t find a light brown one.
As you can see we had lots of fun with this theme.
Cartoon picture credits: Disney
More Family Costume Theme Ideas
This post was originally published November 3, 2012
Leave a Reply